Consecutive Years of Member Dividends – 11

On 12/31/24, our CFO was busy that evening transmitting to our actuaries our entire claims history. That data included date of injury, what was paid so far, and our estimate of what remains to be paid on every claim since 2006. There is lots of detail to send. This data is then sorted by our actuary and trended to get an estimate on the final claims costs for claims that may have just happened in 2024. By getting that assessment of the past 18 years’ worth and applying it to the known and unknown data of 2024, they come up with a final estimate of claims cost for 2024. This actuarial process takes about three weeks and involves them sending it to a second actuary to do a peer review of the entire calculation and data. The net result of this three-week project is a 110-page report that gives MTM the most scientific basis of plugging numbers into our 2024 financial statement. As a mutual insurer, for 11 years it has been the Board of Directors position that profits get returned to our members.

Sean Heinonen
Loss Control Consultant

So you’ve taken the time to identify the hazards in your workplace, now what is your next step in protecting yourself or your employees? Did you know there is a hierarchy of 5 levels for determining the most effective control methods? These methods include elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls and personal protective equipment.

Ruth Kiefer, MSc, ARM
Vice President of Loss Control

Happy New Year to everyone! With the new season upon us I just have some friendly reminders about first posting your form 300A from February 1 through April 30th and electronically submitting the 300A summary if you are a high hazard industry and have over 20 employees by March 2nd. Those who forgot to submit their forms online were fined between $600-$1,400 by MIOSHA.

Donna Motley
Vice President of Claims

By the time you are reading this, we will be into the New Year – 2025! Employees will be returning to work after spending time with family and loved ones. A new year and hopefully a new start to all things good!

What isn’t new in 2025, will be ice and snow resulting in slips and falls. Falling can result in broken bones, concussions, bruised and pulled muscles. As adults, when falling, it is instinct to stick out an arm to try and “break” the fall. What results is a broken bone, dislocated shoulder or torn rotator cuff.

MTM — It’s Members, It’s Board

I am frequently asked “how is MTM different than commercial insurance carriers?” After my 50 years in insurance, many years at a commercial insurance company, it is a question I enjoy answering. The difference between a specialty mutual company owned by its members and a large investor-owned insurance company is huge. Priorities/goals at the top of the small mutual are vastly different from a multi-state, multi-coverage commercial insurance company. So let me start with the MTM Board of Directors and what happened in October.

By Donna Motley
Vice President of Claims

Over the years, our office has received claims involving injured workers who do not speak English, or at best, very limited English. We have been asked “how” we handle these situations. If at all possible, we first inquire whether or not the injured worker has a spouse, significant other, child or other relative that would be able to step in as a translator/interpreter for us. Most injured workers would be most comfortable with a family member intervening. Some employers may have a co-employee facilitate the translation/interpretation process. If a family member or coemployee is not available, we have to hire an outside, professional interpreter. While there may be a couple of Nurse Case Managers that we hire that are “knowledgeable” with a specific language, they cannot act as a formal interpreter. They, obviously, are hired by MTMIC to aid the injured worker and facilitate medical treatment, and as such, are paid by MTMIC and may not be seen as being “impartial”. Translators and interpreters should be certified and/or degreed in the vocation.

Brady Schlesener is Vice President of Sales and Marketing at Gemini Group. He is responsible for overseeing all commercial activities for the company’s 18 locations with $300 million in annual revenue. He has over 23 years of professional experience in the automotive industry and has been with Gemini since 2007. Additionally, he serves on the Manufacturing Technology Mutual Insurance Company Board.

Schlesener holds a Bachelor of Arts, Finance and Marketing, from Cedarville University as well as a Master of Business Administration from Michigan State University. He is a member of various professional organizations including Motors & Equipment Manufacturers Association (MEMA), Aluminum Extrusion Council (AEC), and the Forging Industry Association (FIA). Additionally, he volunteers with the High School Youth Ministry at Highland Park Baptist Church and the Seaholm Football Booster Club.

Where Does the Money Go?

Occasionally I am asked “where does the premium go that is paid by MTM members?” I could break that down into more than two dozen categories but let me just give you a high-level view. If I took 2023 as an example year, I could put the percentages into three basic categories. No surprise, the number one category is claims including legal expenses with the second being administrative expenses which include company salaries, rent and of course, taxes. Not only are there income taxes to pay but we’re also required to pay assessments to the state and a percentage of the premium as a state premium tax. And the third category are the leftover funds which are paid to members as dividends. Again, going back to 2023, in rounded numbers, 55% of the premium is paid out in claims and claims handling costs with 25% paid for MTM administrative expenses and 20% was returned as member dividends.

By Donna Motley, Vice President of Claims

Seems like – what used to be simple, is not so simple anymore! Procedures are established for a reason – to simplify things!

In an ideal world, when an employee is injured at work, the injury is reported to the Supervisor, Safety Representative and/or Human Resource personnel. A claim is filed on the appropriate forms with your Workers’ Compensation carrier (MTMIC !). The employee is sent to the Occupational Clinic where treatment is rendered; the injured worker may be referred to a specialist. The injured worker will treat until the injury is resolved, then discharged from care, and the employee is released back to work. The steps seem pretty cut and dry and while medical care is not considered “cheap” by any means, Michigan Workers’ Compensation includes a fee sched-ule resulting in 40-60% savings on most medical bills. As an employer, I’m sure you are astounded at times, when you see the dollar amount spent on some work related injuries.

Experience Mod Calculation

It’s been some time since I wrote about Michigan workers’ compensation experience modifications and how they affect your workers’ comp premiums, so, it seems time for a refresher course. Experience modifications in Michigan are promulgated out by an outside rating agency that requires membership from all Michigan insurance companies. We submit to them data on every policy six months after it expires. We report payroll by class code and losses for every employer

This agency then produces an individual experience modification that is used by all insurance companies. To better walk you through this process, I’ve attached an exhibit with some letter designations for certain sections. Here is a simple explanation of the entire calculation.

By Travis Halsted, ARM, COSS, Loss Control Consultant

It was just a few months ago that I was discussing icy parking lots, and shoveling snowy walkways with many of you. Oh, how the seasons have changed. As the temperatures rise, so do the risks in the workplace. The brain and body take part in a dance to keep the body cool. Each year, over 600 Americans die from heat exhaustion. While the majority are well aware of the measures that we can put in place to help with heat levels while the employee is working (fans, air conditioning, breaks), I think we could even look at heat preparation from a different angle.

As the health and safety field is based on preventing injuries/accidents, it is paramount that we try to be proactive with employees before they even enter the workplace. The next few items will provide some proactive measures that employees can utilize at work, at home, and really any event where they can expect to enter a high temperature environment.

December 31 conjures up a whole bunch of thoughts. One of the more boring, but required duties is for us to prepare our calendar year profit and loss statements, and get a start on the taxes for the year. You go through the cost of raw materials, the cost/depreciation of equipment, the building expenses, utilities, labor expenses, benefit costs, and in the end hopefully find a profit was yielded. MTM goes through a similar process, and this process is important for not only tax purposes, but to also determine MTM member dividends.

While we go through many of the same things as your shop, there are some differences. The parts that are the same are that we go through the office rent expense, office utility cost, office supply expense, mailing costs, printing, staff wages and staff benefits. All of that matches up pretty well with your shop’s process. In MTM’s case, all of those items only account for 12% to 14% of the MTM total expenses. By far, and not surprising, MTM’s largest expense is paying claims.

By Donna Motley, Vice President of Claims

Work related injuries submitted to our department tend to occur in cycles. At a given time we may see an influx of shoulder injuries, then foot injuries or hernias. What we have been experiencing most recently are injuries involving “teeth”, where an employee either fell and damaged a tooth or teeth, or sustained a blow to the mouth resulting in damage or loss of a tooth or teeth. 

MTM Office and COVID

The MTM Board and Management position has been simple: If member companies are open, MTM needs to be open supporting member activities. Claims still happen, Loss Control services are needed, policy and billing changes occur. Because we never wanted our claims representative to be talking with a member company or injured worker in open space, every MTM employee has a separate office with a door. With this office layout, we have required spacing working at the office.

Here is a department update:

MTM’s Member Dividend Program – 2021

On December 23rd, the MTM Board approved a $3 million member dividend declaration to be paid March 1, 2021. Let me give you more details how the MTM member Board and MTM member Finance Committee came to this decision. Dividends are paid out of annual profits. While the year is not yet over, we have some predictions of what the year looks like, and all, at this point, look to show that 2020 was a profitable year. It is always the goal of the Board Committees and full Board to return profits to our member-owners. So, this process started on Thursday, December 3rd, with the regularly scheduled Board Finance Committee. This Committee is made up of members: Teena Kowalski – Repair Clinic, Barry Kavanagh – Avalon and Tahoe, Gary Sievert – Wellington Industries, Andrew Varenytsia – Romeo Rim, Jerry Decker – Precision Boring, Jack Accardo – Haller International Technologies, Joe Keppler – Shuert Industries and Gerd Walter – Creative Automation and Kurt Heuser. The Committee members took the management recommendation of $2.5 million and questioned management on assumptions and details for the 2020 profit projection. At the end of a hardy discussion, the Committee felt the profit would be likely higher than management suggested, and decided that instead of the $2.5 million profit estimate $3 million was more probable.

Every year, millions of employers are required to keep track of their workers’ injuries and illnesses by recording them in what is often called the “OSHA Logs.” The OSHA Logs consist of three separate documents: the Form 300 Log of Work- Related Injuries and Illnesses, the Form 300-A Summary of Work-Related Injuries and Illness Incident Report. It is required for all applicable employers (employers with 10 or more employees in certain industries) to retain the last five years of each of these documents. MIOSHA (Michigan Occupational Safety and Health Administration) will request to see them as needed during inspections and enforcement actions.

Under a Final Rule (Federal Registry Doc # 2016-10443) that became effective on January 1, 2017, OSHA revised its requirements for recording and submitting records of workplace injuries and illnesses to require that some of this recorded information be submitted to OSHA electronically for posting to the OSHA website via the Injury Tracking Application (ITA). After additional public commentary and feedback from employers, a second Final Rule (Federal Registry Doc # 2019-00101) was published by OSHA amending its original recordkeeping regulation. The current Final Rule was published on January 25, 2019, and made effective on February 25, 2019.

Certificate of Insurance

InsuranceA common request from our members is a Certificate of Insurance. Most often this is requested by a customer of our MTM member. That is a customer of our member is requesting that before they work at the customer’s location, the MTM member provides a Certificate of Insurance. For MTM members who work only at their own shop, a Certificate of Insurance rarely comes up. On the other hand, some of MTM members provide equipment maintenance/ repair/installation at their customer’s location, and this Certificate of Insurance is requested. There are two primary reasons that customers request this from our members.

By Donna Motley, Vice President of Claims

We are all familiar with the proverbial phrase “when life gives you lemons, make lemonade”. Turning a negative into a positive. The power of positive thinking. Lemons into lemonade is good, but, what about when life gives you COVID-19? How can something that has been so impactful or should I say, devastating to our lives and our country have anything “positive” associated with it? We have to adjust and evolve. And we are.

Having to wear a facial mask is now the “norm”. Aside from the health benefits, we are now also turning mask wearing into a fashion statement! You can buy a mask bearing the likeness of your favorite Superhero, Disney character, Sports Team, Flower, etc. You can buy a mask with rhinestones, sequins, beads, lace, fringe, etc. There are special masks made for Brides to wear on their special day! You can even buy a face mask holder/necklace so you can have your mask at your fingertips at any given moment.A global positive was the reduction in air pollution as there were less vehicles on the road. Science magazine reported up to 50% reduction in global seismic noise for the period March thru May, 2020. Amazing!

We have recently updated our website and portal with two new postings to protect automotive service workers from exposure to COVID-19. These postings are available in English and Spanish. If you have questions regarding COVID-19 postings or any required postings please reach out to your loss control representative or contact us at losscontrol@mtmic.com. 

By Chris Demeter, Senior Loss Control Consultant

While everyone loves to relax and enjoy vacations in the warm climates, someone who has to perform vigorous tasks in the hot environment is at risk. Over the years, I have learned to schedule certain accounts such as heat-treat, metal plating, foundries, and forging operations in the cooler months. Even though I am not in a hotshop for an entire shift, I would prefer not to break out in a sweat and then go to my next account. Heat stress can overcome anyone who does not properly acclimate themselves to the heat or watch for the signs and symptoms that may alert them to possible heat stress disorders. Informing employees of all risk factors and heat stress disorders that they may encounter and how to avoid serious complications can greatly reduce the risk of serious injury or death. According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), more than 600 people in the United States die by extreme heat every year. Some people are more at risk of developing a heat-related illness, including adults age 65 and older, those with chronic medical conditions, people who work outside, infants and children and athletes.